A few weeks after the keys are handed over, it turns out that the cellar leaks, the walls are mouldy or the wiring is dangerous. The seller says the buyer bought the property “as viewed”, so there is nothing to discuss. This is one of the most common property disputes in Hungary, and the answer is rarely as simple as sellers suggest. Below I summarise what you can expect as a buyer, and as a seller.
What counts as a hidden defect?
The seller’s performance is defective if, at handover, the property does not meet the quality requirements laid down in the contract or by law: it is not fit for its normal use, or it lacks the qualities agreed in the contract. A hidden defect is one the buyer could not have recognised at the viewing by simple inspection, without special expertise. Typical examples:
- damp, leaks and mould concealed under the plaster;
- outdated or non-compliant electrical wiring and plumbing;
- structural defects in the floors, the roof or the foundations;
- legal defects, such as alterations carried out without a permit.
The seller is not liable for a defect the buyer knew of, or should have known of, when the contract was signed. If the crack in the wall was plainly visible, or the seller pointed it out in writing, the buyer cannot rely on it later. On the other hand, the seller’s liability does not depend on whether they knew of the defect: they answer for hidden defects even if they were unaware of them.
What does “as viewed” mean?
Almost every Hungarian sale contract states that the buyer purchases the property “in the condition viewed” (megtekintett állapotban). This does not in itself release the seller. It only means that the buyer knows and accepts the defects that can be recognised on inspection. It does not cover defects that cannot be seen, because a buyer cannot be expected to open up the walls or have the house examined by experts.
The position is different if the contract expressly excludes the statutory warranty for defects (kellékszavatosság). Between private individuals this is permitted, and courts usually accept it, especially where the price reflected it. It has two limits, however: an exclusion does not protect a seller who knew of the defect and deliberately concealed it, and it does not extend to qualities expressly promised in the contract. As a buyer, check whether your contract contains “as viewed” wording or a genuine warranty exclusion, because the difference is considerable.
What can the buyer claim?
The warranty rights have two tiers:
- First tier: repair. The buyer may primarily demand that the seller repair the defect within a reasonable deadline. If the seller refuses or fails to do so, the buyer may have the defect repaired and claim the cost.
- Second tier: price reduction or withdrawal. If repair is impossible or disproportionate, or the seller does not carry it out, the buyer may claim a proportionate reduction of the price or, as a last resort, withdraw from the contract. Withdrawal is not available for an insignificant defect.
On top of the warranty claim, damages can be claimed for further losses caused by the defective performance, such as furniture ruined by a leak or the cost of renting during the repairs. The seller is exempt only on proving that the defect arose from an unforeseeable cause outside their control.
How long does the buyer have?
- For real estate, the warranty claim becomes time-barred five years after performance, that is, after handover, which is much longer than for movable goods.
- The defect must be notified to the seller without delay after it is discovered. The buyer bears the loss resulting from late notification, and silence also makes proof harder.
- If the buyer could only recognise the defect later for an excusable reason, the limitation period is suspended, so the claim is not lost immediately when the five years expire.
- For newly built homes, the builder also owes a mandatory guarantee (jótállás), which may run longer depending on the building element concerned.
Who proves what?
In a sale between private individuals, the buyer must prove that the defect already existed at handover and could not have been recognised at the viewing. The seller, in turn, may prove that the buyer knew of the defect or that it arose after handover through the buyer’s use. Most cases therefore turn on expert evidence: whether the damp is old or recent, and whether the wiring is original or was altered later, is determined by a court-appointed expert.
What to do if you find a hidden defect
- Document it immediately: dated photographs and video; do not have the defect repaired before the seller has had a chance to inspect it.
- Notify the seller in writing, by registered letter and e-mail, and invite them to inspect and repair the defect by a set deadline.
- Obtain an expert opinion: a written opinion from an architect, structural engineer or building services engineer on the cause of the defect and the cost of repair is the basis for negotiation and can be used in court. For larger losses, a forensic expert opinion carries more weight.
- Negotiate: a large share of disputes is settled by a price reduction or by sharing the repair costs, without litigation.
- If there is no agreement: a court action for the cost of repair, a price reduction or damages.
Notes for foreign buyers
- Commission a survey before you sign. A pre-purchase building survey is neither mandatory nor customary in Hungary, and the attorney who countersigns the contract checks the legal position, not the technical condition. An independent survey costs little compared with a later dispute.
- Buying from a distance. If you buy without viewing the property in person, have someone inspect it on your behalf and keep the report. The “as viewed” clause will be applied to you as well.
- Get disclosures in writing. Ask the seller to list the known defects in the contract, and in a bilingual contract make sure both language versions say the same.
The costs of a purchase and the attorney’s role are covered in my guide Buying Property in Hungary: Lawyer’s Fees, Taxes and Costs.
In my experience, the outcome of hidden-defect cases is decided in the first few weeks. A buyer who documents the defect at once and reports it in writing negotiates from a strong position; one who waits for months and has it repaired in the meantime destroys their own evidence. The wording of the contract matters to both sides: a precise list of known defects is worth more than any general clause.
Questions about your own case?
I advise clients in English and Hungarian, in person in Győr and Mosonmagyaróvár or by video call from anywhere in the world. The 20,000 HUF consultation fee is fully credited against my fee if you retain me.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Fees, duties and thresholds are set by law and change from time to time; every case is different – please contact me about your specific situation.